ButterBall Farms Inc.

Making Flavored Butter: DIY vs. Working With a Manufacturer

The modern food service industry calls for constant innovation and differentiation to not only satisfy customers’ tastebuds but also stand out from the competition. Flavored butter, also called compound butter, is a popular way to imbue culinary creations with a little extra pizzazz.

Compound butter, as the name suggests, is butter that has been compounded with different ingredients, such as spices or fresh herbs. It’s an easy way to quickly elevate and add craveworthy flavor to any dish. Flavored butter allows food service professionals to create flavor combinations they might not otherwise have been able to achieve. However, the decision to incorporate flavored butter into your menu will prompt an important question: should you DIY your compound butter, or should you work with a manufacturer?

Should You DIY Flavored Butter?

Unfortunately, there are several disadvantages to making flavored butter for restaurants or other food service establishments in-house. Working with a professional manufacturer can eliminate the following challenges so you can focus on creating great food.

  • Time and labor costs: Creating flavored butter requires time, specialized equipment, and skilled labor, all of which are valuable commodities in a busy kitchen. The process involves sourcing ingredients, preparing the butter base, infusing it with flavors, and ensuring that each batch meets the chef’s standards. This time-consuming process can divert attention from other critical tasks and create an inefficient kitchen, particularly if your kitchen is already short-staffed. 
  • Ingredient sourcing and storage: Sourcing high-quality ingredients for flavored butter can be challenging, particularly for businesses that require large quantities or have specific requirements (e.g., organic, non-GMO). Additionally, proper storage of these ingredients to maintain freshness and prevent spoilage adds another layer of complexity. Managing inventory and ensuring that ingredients are used before they expire can be a logistical headache that leads to potential waste and increased costs.
  • Consistency: In a commercial setting, customers expect uniformity of flavor, texture, and quality, regardless of when or where they experience your dish. Achieving this level of consistency with in-house production can be difficult, especially as your operation scales up. Variations in ingredient quality, preparation methods, and storage conditions can all lead to inconsistencies that can quickly take your butter from “This is amazing!” to “Why isn’t it as good this time?”
  • Regulatory compliance: Producing food products in-house requires strict adherence to health and safety regulations. Your flavored butter must meet all necessary guidelines, including proper labeling, allergen management, and sanitation standards. Any lapses in compliance can result in costly fines, recalls, or damage to your business’s reputation.
  • Limited scalability: As your business grows, demand for your flavored butter will too. However, it can be difficult to scale production in-house, especially for kitchens that lack the necessary equipment, space, or staff to handle the demand. These limitations can restrict your ability to expand your offerings and ultimately hinder your growth potential.

Why Butterball® Farms Is the Better Choice

The DIY approach to flavored butter may seem appealing, but the complexities and risks involved make it a less viable option for many commercial food operations. Instead, partnering with a specialized manufacturer like Butterball® Farms makes it effortless to create amazing dishes with compound butter for restaurants and other food service providers.

1. Consistency & Quality Control

At Butterball® Farms, we are renowned for our commitment to quality and consistency. We have over 65 years of experience producing specialty restaurant butters, so we’ve perfected our process to make sure each batch meets your high standards for taste, texture, and appearance. You can also be confident that we craft each batch according to stringent safety standards. Your butter is created, stored, and shipped with the well-being of your customers in mind.

2. Expertise & Innovation

Developing unique and innovative flavored butters requires a deep understanding of ingredients, flavor profiles, and production techniques. Butterball® Farms brings this expertise to the table. From spicy soy ginger to brown butter sage and beyond, our research and development division is constantly creating craveworthy flavor combinations to wow your customers. 

What’s more, our butter looks as good as it tastes. We offer a wide variety of shaped butters to delight your guests during table service, from classic Butterball® Butter Premium Balls® to elegant roses and fleur-de-lis

3. Resource Efficiency

Outsourcing flavored butter production to Butterball® Farms frees up valuable time and resources in your kitchen. Instead of dedicating staff to the labor-intensive process of making butter, you can focus on preparing and serving exceptional dishes. By entrusting your flavored butter prep to us, you can improve efficiency, reduce the chance of inconsistent buter, improve food turnaround times, and delight your customers.

4. Scalability

Butterball® Farms offers scalable production capabilities that can grow with your business. Whether you’re launching new locations, expanding your menu, or catering large events, we can accommodate your increasing demands without compromising on quality or consistency. This scalability ensures that you’re always prepared to dazzle the tastebuds of your customers, regardless of the size or scope of your food service operation.

5. Easy Customization

One of the best parts of working with Butterball® Farms is the ability to customize every aspect of your commercial flavored butter, from flavor to shape and quantity. Whether you have a specific flavor in mind or need help brainstorming new ideas, Butterball® Farms’ team of experts can collaborate with you to create the perfect butter to bring your culinary vision to life. 

Choose a Trusted Partner in Flavored Butter

If you’re wondering where to buy flavored butter, look no further. At Butterball® Farms, we imagine butter differently, and you’re invited to join us! Contact our team today, and let’s transform your butter from basic to the best.